Bobbi Brown Everything Mascara

I too am surprised by the negative reviews. For an everyday mascara that doesn't smudge, doesn't get spidery or make my lashes look sharp at the tips, this is great. I love this mascara. It stays on all day. Its a very natural looking mascara.It does what it is supposed to do! Its just a nice basic mascara that makes my lashes look great! It keeps the curl all day. It definitely does what it says. The packaging is fabulous too! It's so chic.